Nancy Garufi

July 12, 1937 - March 01, 2021

Nancy's Obituary

Oneonta - Nancy Garufi, 83, passed away Monday, March 1, 2021 at A.O. Fox Nursing Home in Oneonta.

She was born on July 12, 1937 in Frazzano, Sicily, the daughter of Lorenzo and Rosalia Frisenda.

At 18 years old, Nancy came to the United States and settled in Cold Spring, NY. Her first job was at the dress factory there.

She married Agatino “Tino” Garufi Sr. in August of 1961.  He predeceased her on June 27, 1998.

Moving to Otego in 1973, she and her husband became co-owners of Pizzaland with Tino’s sister, Frances and husband, Peter until 1982.  In 1985, Nancy and Tino opened their own restaurant Tino’s Pizza.  She enjoyed making salads and knew her customers by their order- “Nancy knows what I want”.  Nancy retired in 2017.

Nancy was a member of St. Mary’s Catholic Church and enjoyed traveling to the 1,000 Islands and Florida.

She is survived by her two wonderful sons, Tino Garufi Jr. and his wife, Debbie and their two sons, Tino III and Joshua, and Vincent Garufi and his two daughters, Alissa and Cassondra and his companion, Jennifer Mannion (Alex and Carter); her special nieces and nephews, Peter Puglisi (Patty) and their three children, Peter, Jessica and Michaela, and Sarah Lynch (Daniel) and their three children, Kevin, Patrick and Katie whom is also her goddaughter; as well as nieces, Rosalia, Tina and Anna Maria, nephew Lorenzo and their families.

Nancy was predeceased by her brothers, John and Ubaldo.

Calling hours will be held Monday, March 8, 2021 from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. at the Lewis, Hurley & Pietrobono Funeral Home, 51 Dietz Street, Oneonta.  Please wear a face covering, maintain social distancing and be prepared to wait to enter the building.

A private funeral mass will be held at the convenience of the family at St. Mary’s Catholic Church in Oneonta with the Rev. David Mickiewicz as celebrant.

Burial will be at Mt. Calvary Cemetery at a later date.

In honor of Nancy, anyone she has ever made a salad for, please raise a fork in her memory.

Memorial contributions in loving memory of Nancy may be made to a Heart Association of your choice.

Condolences may be sent to the family at

To plant Memorial Trees in memory of Nancy Garufi, please click here to visit our Sympathy Store.

Wake/Calling hours

Lewis, Hurley & Pietrobono Funeral Home
  • Email Details
  • 51 Dietz Street
    Oneonta, New York 13820
  • Please wear face cover, maintain social distancing and be prepared to wait to enter the building.

Plant Trees In Remembrance

Honor a loved one by planting trees in their memory.

Learn More